Major revision vs minor revision. Indeed, the author of an .

Major revision vs minor revision Especially if you are unsure about how to formulate your feedback. ” The reviewers left only one comment, and the editor said that the work was well received. Basically, brush up and explain your methodology better and work on the conclusion about generalisability and so on. Also, according to you, the major revision comments do not all seem to be valid or well-informed. The number will not change until I start a new project of the same program name. Recruiting new reviewers to evaluate a minor revision is very non-standard. However, when I read the reviews, they seem very minor. maintenance[. THANKS!! Dec 6, 2022 · major. We have revised the manuscript again responding to all the third reviewer highlighted points (some points are not responsible for that reason we submitted a rebuttal letter to the editor before sending the revision). I'm currently trying to write the supporting documentation but I've got stuck on defining the difference between a major change (new part number) and a minor change (new revision). Major Revision is great news! Pretty much everybody in the labs that I work in has major/minor revisions. 01 vs 20. Jul 13, 2021 · I got a major revision (one reviewer with minor while second almost rejected it) after submitting paper to renowned journal. The authors analysed reviews of treatment for type II diabetes and concluded that doctors who rely on reviews may be misled. fix. Sep 23, 2003 · So while the new part can be made to substitute on the old part it is a minor revision to make. The associate editor makes one of four recommendations for publication: accept, accept with minor revisions, major revisions required with no guarantee of acceptance, and reject. This guide will help you understand how to handle these two types of revisions effectively. Jun 1, 2015 · To test the effect of inter-reviewer variability, we were interested in the comparison of just three pairs of reviewer recommendations, with the first member of the pair having more agreement between reviewers and the second member having less agreement between reviewers: (1) minor revision (agreement among the two reviewers) vs. In conclusion, version and revision are two concepts that are crucial in the development and management of web applications. 2. After submitting major revision, I got minor revision with only one comment from editor, while one reviewer accepted it (it was not sent to second reviewer). These revisions accumulate and may result in a new version of the text, such as the second edition of a book. Personally, I consider revisions “easy”, regardless of whether the editor has classified the manuscript decision as “Major Revisions” versus “Minor Revisions”, if no additional experiments need to be performed. I never saw a journal defining its "major revision vs. Editors may prefer not to explicitly say that the paper is "accepted with minor revisions", because authors may make "minor revisions" that don't correct the problems, and then feel that they've been promised publication in spite of that. Overall, minor changes that don't really affect your thesis. z. Dec 8, 2019 · I am not sure if the initial revision requested was a major revision or a minor revision. After submitting, you will often receive feedback from peer reviewers. Major revision; Minor revision; Accept; If after peer review a manuscript is considered potentially appropriate for PLOS Medicine, a major revision is generally requested. This not only ensures that the project remains on track but also fosters a collaborative environment where both the client and the team can thrive. major revision이나, minor revision이면 리뷰어의 심사에 따라 논문을 수정해서 보내야 한다. g. 7 ± 65. The following code example demonstrates the Version constructor, and Major, Minor, Build, Revision, MajorRevision, and MinorRevision properties. 2", and personnel are allowed to use May 20, 2015 · In the geosciences (geology, geophysics, physical geography, atmospheric sciences), “accept with minor revisions” and “accept subject to major revisions” are quite standard and prevalent, probably making up the majority of initial manuscript decisions. Many organizations use major revisions alone Nov 23, 2024 · Gets the high 16 bits of the revision number. Typically authors are given a deadline for submitting revisions. In reality, the threshold is completely arbitrary and depends on reviewer/editor and what they had for lunch. What is the correct formulae to combine the major and minor revisions? Thanks Nov 14, 2013 · A good practice is to use 3 level revision numbers: x. 5% are asked to resubmit. 6. Yes, characterizing revisions as "minor" strongly suggests that if you make those revisions the paper will be accepted. 何日かは 論文誌や論文によって違うので、正確な数字は言えません 。 ただここでは例として、私が典型的だと思っている私の2つの論文(Nature communicationsとSensir and actuator IFは3. See full list on publishingsupport. On the other hand, I also had a minor revision, that in the end turned out to require a significant (>50%) rewriting of the paper that took quite some time; I'd definitely classify it as major revision. stewart@comdev. However, they are worth a try. Pharma; Researcher Services; English Editing; Learning Lab Menu Toggle. I'd say maybe 40 were "minor revision. So, a review of your paper will generally indicate that you need to make either minor or major revisions. Whatever you choose, make sure you include it in your I use Major. Aug 22, 2022 · It’s a judgement call, but it has to do with time and resources. For software, it makes sense. Apr 22, 2019 · @Buffy Almost every single journal instructs me to "apply highest standards" (or other similar wording), irrespective of its position in the journal pecking order. major: We increase this number when saved file from this build are no longer compatible with previous build. revision. This feedback leads to the next key step: revising your manuscript. Major revisions are generally reserved for larger changes like actual modification to geometry, while smaller changes such as documentation updates or fixing the spelling on a drawing would generally be classified as a minor revision. Despite this, the third revision indicated that all his/her concerns were "fully addressed" in the first round of revision. This requires more extensive revision than regular major revisions and the possibility of moving forward in the review process is lower than the manuscripts under regular major revisions. For example = A-01, B-01, C-01, C-02, C-03 etc. Minor revision = confident the authors can take care of any issues without the key findings changing, don't need to see manuscript again. A writer might revise a paragraph to improve clarity or correct errors. Acceptance with major revisions. Contents Examples Sep 21, 2023 · If a major CRT has contents which overlaps an ongoing minor CRT, then the links to both CRTs should be provided in the replies of said CRTs. Roughly five were accept without revision. Authors receiving a major revision decision are usually given a specific set of instructions or feedback from the reviewers and editors on what needs to be addressed. " The remaining 40 fell into the "revise and resubmit" or "major revision" or some similar Peer-reviewing an academic manuscript is not an easy task. build makes the most sense to me. 1. It says “minor revisions”, but doesn’t explicitly say “accepted with minor revisions. revisions are bug fixes or tweaks, minor are additions and changes that don't break existing APIs or behavior, major breaks API or adds features that change how the existing version works. At others, the difference is less clear-cut and may simply reflect the editor's feeling of how many additional rounds of review may be necessary. ) I know that revisions, both major and minor, hint at a higher chance of acceptance. These are empirical cases and not subjective at all. 'Minor revisions’ means that a manuscript only has to undergo small changes and improvements before it can be published in an academic journal. Our version numbers are now [major]. Feb 19, 2023 · Versions are typically used to differentiate between major changes in a product, while revisions are used to describe minor changes. The author of a manuscript which has received an accept with major revisions decision is to be congratulated, as the editors have concluded that the paper contains a publishable contribution when a list of specified revisions is successfully executed. Major revisions will have to be addressed by additional experiments. Nov 11, 2014 · We have an ASP. Aug 30, 2010 · I am back at it again, this time with a new company. This is a bad idea - the preferred way to do it is through proper version Jan 1, 2023 · For a minor revision, the editor may decide to send the revised manuscript to the peer reviewer for a final check or review the manuscript themselves if the changes were indeed minor. Just thinking back the past decade, I've had about 90 publication submissions. Conditional acceptance pending major revision: Once the article has been revised, it may be sent out for peer review again to the same or different reviewers. The paper was then sent to two new reviewers. Rather, they represent an integral step in achieving the desired outcome. Minor revision will be for documentation changes only to the drawing that defines the part. A minor revision will be uploaded as an approved document, immediately available to all appropriate employees. Personally I determine my version codes by multiplying each part by a factor: Major x 10,000 But "minor revision" means "if you do the listed revisions, and they don't meaningfully change the content of the paper, it'll be accepted". This is the outcome that all PhD candidates want (or no corrections!)! If people receive this outcome than supervisors send out congratulatory emails to everyone and refer to the PhD candidate as 'Dr so and so'. Here are some tips for making minor revisions: Read your work aloud. 0 won't be compatible with version 2. Eugene Stewart< ">mailto:eugene. Jan 8, 2013 · c) Hardware revision. You fixed some bugs. Authors of manuscripts with a Minor Revision or a Major Revision decision are invited to submit their revised work through ScholarOne Manuscripts as a revision. Minor: I changed the internal behavior. I have setup a test environment with the latest version of Innovator (9. If an editor thinks authors need more time than a major revision decision would allow, they should use the “revise and resubmit” option. Revise and resubmit, however, is likely followed by a rejection. To sum up, “Revise and resubmit as new” can be considered as a “Serious Major Revision”. Knowing how to respond to both minor and major revisions can greatly affect your chances of getting published. Apr 7, 2016 · The exact semantics of major or minor revisions will depend on the journal - at some journals, a minor revision will not be externally reviewed any more, while a major revision will. Aug 19, 2020 · Almost all students are given minor or major corrections - I'd say 90% fall into these categories. In the revision block, you can state that you corrected spelling, and that there is no change to the as-fabricated part I do not recognize a difference between major and minor revisions on a fabricated part. These small changes can often make a big difference in the overall quality of your writing. Whenever the minor number is incremented, the revision number is set to 0. minor revision format, and personnel need only be concerned with the major portion. Jun 9, 2019 · Hello all!By popular demand, here is a new ENOVIA Video dealing about Minor and Major Revisions in 3DExperience Release 19x. Major revision = key findings may or may not be different and/or critiques may or may not be successfully addressed, would need to see manuscript again to be certain. First, we have to create our revision numbering components… Nov 12, 2020 · Even if it is a major revision, the due date is 24 November, which is 13 days ahead, quite bizarre for a "major revision". For example, a revision scheme that uses alphabetical major revisions and numeric minor revisions as shown here A-01, B-01, B-02, C-01… or any other combination of major or minor schemes. Such revisions necessitate conceptual reorganization, proper judgment, and the investment of considerable time and serious effort by the author. Clarification: Sep 14, 2023 · These changes, known as design revisions, range from minor adjustments like shifting colors to major transformations like layout overhauls. Revision. fixing a typo or typographical changes). Decision Types Accept - No further revision required. A0, A1, B0, B1, etc. So let’s round it up: Minor revisions imply a change of Basically, minor revisions were along the lines of "the variables in the main text in chapter 3 must be in italics" or "there's a typo on page 122" and "Figure 4. 3. 1; Major minor patch + commitHash e. Shared libraries in Solaris and Linux may use the current Mar 12, 2014 · So that what used to be minor revisions are now considered major revisions, and what used to be major revisions are now grounds for rejection. Unfortunately, the . Some like to use an alphanumeric code (e. After submitting their manuscripts to academic journals, authors receive one of several editorial decisions: 'desk reject', 'revise and resubmit', 'major revisions', 'minor revisions', or 'paper accepted. 01. The editors of the Journal of Monetary Economics have concluded that your paper contains a contribution that is publishable when a small list of specified revisions is successfully executed. major: For me is the current project I am working on. 3 days (Minor Revision) and 27. Unless you have alternative build tools controling the build and revision number according to some other scheme I can see no real advantage to setting them manually. Indeed, the author of an Jan 19, 2022 · Major revision. However, changing a short text phrase here and there is usually considered a minor revision. 2 of my papers came back as major revisions but it took maybe 2 hours of editing grammer and spelling to Revision: Assemblies with the same name, major, and minor version numbers but different revisions are intended to be fully interchangeable. 审稿决定“Major revision” 意味着你的论文有被接受的机会，但是审稿人要求做一些实质性的、重要的修改。针对审稿人的审稿意见的修改预计肯定需要比“小修”和“大修”更长的时间，期刊编辑将允许提交修回论文更长的截止日期。 Then you will make an assembly with 2 parts. A higher revision number might be used in a build that fixes a security hole in a previously released assembly. major. Oct 31, 2016 · I'm using the following code to combine the major and minor revisions. Jan 5, 2021 · If you think the issues with the manuscript can be fixed, the authors should be given the chance to do a revision - if those are major issues, or a large number of issues, then a major revision. 5くらい)の日数をお見せします。 You can also charge different rates depending on the nature and extent of the revision, such as minor tweaks, major changes, or new concepts. They might just not work out in principle, or the authors might not be capable of pulling them off. Dec 3, 2018 · How to create a SOLIDWORKS PDM Revision Numbering System for major and minor revisions. 0 days (Major Revision) for third resubmissions. org I think one important practical difference between minor and major revisions is the revising time granted to the authors. I submitted the minor revision on the same day, status was with editor for 6 days but now its two weeks the 'Major revisions' is one of the most common peer review decisions. English Editing Research Services. Of these, I estimate that five were rejected (either desk rejected or reviewed and rejected). Maybe 8% get no corrections, and perhaps 1. Examples. A minor revision is close to a contract to publish the paper if certain changes are made. Major revisions may require simply moving parts of the text around, or they may require the authors to reanalyze the data and rewrite the whole manuscript. If this is right, is it really the case that close to half of R&R papers are ultimately rejected? Mar 12, 2021 · A publication accepting an article in its current form with no revisions is very rare. An administ rative modification is a revision that does not Nov 21, 2022 · After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. minor: We increase this number when a new feature has been added. First you will see how to enable Feb 28, 2019 · Minor revisions - the best you can hope for after the first round of review Major revisions - the decision we received in this case Reject – clearly, the one you want to avoid; Editors are most likely to write back to you after initial review and recommend either ‘minor revisions’ or ‘major revisions’ to your paper. That does indeed sound bizarre (even if journal timescales are very field-dependent). But for to make the major revisions is to make parts that become not backwards campatability. All defined components must be integers greater than or equal to 0. platform. 7 version of the product. The new revision has the same content ID as the previous revision, but the native file and the metadata can be the same or different. and major revision, yet is unsure of what the quality of the next revision would look like. [Minor]. however, for minor revisions, the editor often does not feel the need to send the paper to external reviewers again. Slightly more in minor corrections probably. Giving the best answer to this question is important because major revisions to studies that have been heard by the Full […] Sep 1, 2009 · I can then increment the Major and Minor version numbers as seems appropriate and let the default DateTime base build and revision be automatically set. 3 reviewers were involved. Linux hasn't used that semantic versioning in a long time. A 16-bit signed integer. NET WebForms application with standard versioning numbering in this format: [Major]. Very, very few fail outright. build]] (example: 1. The vast majority of minor revisions are ultimately accepted for publication, while many more major revisions are later found unacceptable and rejected. [Build]. The problems with “revise and resubmit as new” are the following: Acceptance with minor revisions. Build. Oct 20, 2015 · Of course a decent chance is not 100%. 1; Major minor patch e. So when new part is compatible with exsisting already parts it is small revision but if not backward compatible then it became major. It means that the peer reviewer considers a manuscript suitable for publication if the authors rectify some major shortcomings. The majority of articles require revision before reaching this stage. 3 Major revision , if there are major concerns about ethics, study design, reporting of results, generalizability of the findings, or composition of the manuscript; a revised manuscript may result in Nov 23, 2024 · The minor version number. In my field (medical applications of physics, let's say) minor revision (at the first revision) is purely theoretical. Blog For a review journal like The Lancet Neurology, it is rather worrying that the results of a cohort analysis published recently in the BMJ suggest that review articles are not as accurate and reliable as most clinicians think (BMJ 2003; 327: 266). When a paper receives a minor revision decision, it might not be sent for a second round of peer review; usually, the editor goes through the revisions and gives a final approval. revision (possibly because Microsoft used to only use 3 version places?). Sep 14, 2023 · What is the difference between a major and a minor revision for a Content Server item? Each time that you check out a file and check it back in, Content Server creates a new revision of that file. So, focus Revision: Assemblies with the same name, major, and minor version numbers but different revisions are intended to be fully interchangeable. Revision: set to * which means they reflect the time it was built. Usually, you would see “Minor Revisions Required” or “Major Revisions Required” if the journal wants you to revise your manuscript to address specific concerns raised by the editor/reviewers. 1" would be "revision 1. Does it mean Minor revision? Does the manuscript with this decision, go back to the original/new reviewers or the editor him/herself evaluate the manuscript? Kindly reply. Nov 2, 2023 · Revisions typically focus on the details and quality of the content. If the major CRT's overlapping part conflicts with the minor CRT, such part of CRT should be better discussed in the minor CRT first. 0 ± 0. Feb 28, 2014 · Under such a system there would be a major. Then, the email arrives, and… Feb 27, 2024 · 'Major revisions' vs. This is the second round of revisions; two months ago, we received a “major revisions” decision with many detailed comments from the reviewers. Hope this was helpful :) Nov 8, 2015 · The scope of the journal is related to education. ) 이 논문의 경우 minor revision이기 때문에 대체로 까다롭지 않은 간단한 수정만해서 보내면 게재될 수 있을 것으로 생각된다. As a peer reviewer, it is useful to learn about common reasons for a 'major revision' verdict. Contents The meaning of a 'desk-rejected' paperWhat to do if your paper is desk-rejectedThe meaning of 'revise and Apr 24, 2018 · This discussion is also important for understanding the likely amount of effort required to get the manuscript accepted. 1+a2b3c4d5; Or any other format as defined in Semantic Versioning; The versionCode, however, must remain an integer which must be greater than the previous version. Sep 10, 2020 · the minor revisions being changed into major revisions is uncommon, but given the seemingly poor quality of the reviews it is understandable if the editor read the paper afterwards The papers I have reviewed myself that lack the basics such a motivation, conclusion and references always had many other problems and I have always had to recommend Mar 29, 2017 · A major revision goes back to reviewers, while the minor revision goes to the (associate) editor for a decision. So I'm wondering which one this response is. Though I have often considered a major/minor revision level system (e. Minor Revision - A limited number of changes are required. e. One recommended major revision, two recommended minor revision, and one recommended acceptance. 7. Acceptance conditional on minor revisions means the editor is confident the revisions can be completed straightforwardly, while major revisions are always more of a gamble. [revision / 10000]. Whenever the major number is incremented, the minor and revision numbers are set to 0. This change has occurred After months—sometimes years—of research, writing, and editing, you finally hit “submit” and begin the anxious wait for feedback. y. Two were happy with my first round of revision; the third reviewer is the one who asked me to undertake another round of (major) revision. ) whereby the first letter is major revision, second letter is minor revision, with the assumption that all rev A PCBs are interchangeable, all rev B PCBs are interchangeable, etc. Whilst I am happy to define a major change as anything affecting fit, form, or function, I'm not actually sure how to define a minor change other than as the Feb 18, 2020 · Comments: You seem to have received comments from two reviewers, one for a minor revision and the other for a major revision. Feb 22, 2021 · Whether a revised manuscript will be sent for another round of reviews is the sole decision of the handling editor; while it's virtually guaranteed for a major revision, it may or may not happen for a minor revision based on the specific comments, the responses to them, and how confident the editor feels about evaluating themselves whether the Jun 6, 2021 · Why is it important to distinguish between minor and major revisions? Question 3. Contrary to popular belief, these revisions aren’t a sign of inefficiency or a gap in understanding between client and designer. To access the version history of a file, page, or item, right-click on the document and click Version History. Bonus: Creates a variable based on the git revision number (like a subversion revision number). minor. Implies that the editors and reviewers feel the paper is publishable once their comments have been addressed. 2) and was surprised to see not much has changed with the way it handles revisions. In the case of minor revisions, your research supervisor will withhold their signature from the Doctoral Dissertation Approval form at the end of the defence; they will sign the form after checking that the required revisions have been completed. At journals that distinguish between major and minor revisions, I take major to be the default R&R decision, with minor revisions being closer to a conditional acceptance. 0 would this be the first maintenance release to the 1. 03 part- when you install a newer minor revision it will overwrite the older minor rev of the same major rev. Never saw that happen. Any changes NOT affecting relevant data would be a minor change (subject to relaxed control measures). Made it faster, fixed a bug, etc Only people affected by bugs or performance should notice. 0 on the Revision Smart Form asks teams whether the revision they are submitting is a minor revision or a major revision. Editor sent it back with major revisions needed. NET Version type is defined as major. Minor revisions can include many items within the paper that need to be revised, but typically not a major shift or addition to the paper. Mar 28, 2021 · Major revision. The good news is that the comments were mainly suggestions for the lit review, offering citations to add and incorporate to strengthen the article. Utility. Conclusion: Version Vs. However, it is good to remember that an ‘accept with minor revisions’ decision does not guarantee acceptance. You will open the parts separately and perform a minor revision on the first part and a major revision on the second part. Major revisions are for when you've done something seriously wrong on a large scale, and the committee needs it to be fixed, but they don't anticipate it changing your overall results, and thus they feel it's possible for you to just rewrite portions of your work but not have to go through another defense. Agreed. If the initial revision was a major revision, there may be another round of major/minor revision requested on resubmission. For branding projects, ‘can it be more of a blue-green’ or ‘can the icon be a little smaller’ are minor revisions but ‘can I see another variation of the logo’ is a major revision. Major versions use sequential numbering when you make changes to the content (document, item, page, etc. I remember the first time I got a major revision I sort of panicked too, but from my experience this is totally unnecessary! So congratulations, enjoy the moment and, go make that rebuttal! (We had four reviewers. iop. Jun 25, 2022 · Is it a major revision or a minor revision or a rejection (because it is already the third round of review)? Edit: The report from the referee is simple, it only asks about one of our figures because of some confusion from the referee's side. In that case, the editor could make a “Risky Revision” decision. Dec 26, 2024 · Revision: A revision, on the other hand, typically denotes minor changes made to a document without altering its core structure. , accept, minor revision, major revision, reject and resubmit, and reject). Examples of reviewer comments can help! Here you can find an overview of sample comments and examples for the most common review decisions: 'minor revisions', 'major revisions', 'revise and resubmit' and 'reject' decisions. Any change to actual relevant data would be a major revision change (subject to full control measures). Oct 29, 2016 · Calling w the version, x the major revision and y the minor revision is semantic versioning using change significance. Once something was called a major revision, but in my opinion it was minor - it took me only a few hours and the paper was accepted. Minor revision might be a few weeks, major revisions might be a month or two. Typically, editors would be more lenient on the revision time frame if they see a major revision recommendation from the reviewer. • Same or higher Major Revision • Minor Revision as follows: – If the Major Revision is the same, the Minor Revision must be the same or higher. 8 ± 11. Depending on the extent of the minor revision, the editor may decide not to send it out for re-review. reject" policy. Administrative modification means a minor revision that includes minor changes to project/ project phase costs, minor changes to funding sources of previously-included projects, and minor changes to project/ project phase initiation dates. Build. Jun 17, 2020 · Other than the 20. Aug 3, 2023 · In case we need to get a Major and Minor revision on revise for the business users we would need to customize the entire revise functionality in that case? Probably give it as a drop down on revise page for a minor and manjor revision. The revised manuscript will days (Minor Revision) and 73. So, unless you are unlucky enough to have either or both of those you should only have one installation of each major rev. As the author of a manuscript which has received an accept with minor revisions decision, you are to be congratulated. One way to check this would be to look at time series data on submission and acceptance rates at selective journals. ca> Senior Windchill Administrator Com Dev May 11, 2018 · 一般而言，投稿到期刊，審稿完之後，下面是幾個常用的評審結果： accept accept pending on minor revisions minor revision major revision reject reject 還分成兩種，一種是desk reject，表示在editor這關就過不了，沒送外審；一種是外審之後，覺得品質未達到，所以拒絕。 現在有些期刊還加上了新的評審結果：reject After submitting, you will often receive feedback from peer reviewers. The general example steps detailed below can be modified to This refers to the nature and scope of the revisions required by your examining committee. Jan 31, 2022 · This can be further broken down into major and minor revisions. The corresponding author is responsible for submitting the revision. Jul 29, 2009 · We decided to use the same convention, and due to the limitations of Windows version numbers we chose to drop the "micro" part of our version numbers in order to preserve the revision number. Until 2003, Linux used odd-even versions (odd numbers are unstable, even numbers are stable). There is still no guarantee of acceptance at this stage but the chances are certainly higher than at initial submission. Authors should consider this decision as major revision, and resubmit with asking for reviewer continuity and attaching an author response. The following code example demonstrates the Version constructor, and the Major, Minor, Build, Revision, MajorRevision, and MinorRevision properties. After that, you will implement the new revision in the assembly using product edition in ENOVIA collaborative lifecycle application. Apr 1, 2010 · Minor revision, if the work has minor problems that once corrected should lead to acceptance for publication after satisfactory revision. 1 days (Major Revision) and decreased with each subse- quent resubmission to 9. x is the major y is the minor z are bug fixes. Nov 9, 2024 · By identifying major versus minor changes, engaging in open dialogue, and maintaining a proactive approach, teams can effectively manage the revision process. Major Versions. Usually version is split into major and minor verosion, hence small changes will change the minor version number and bigger changes will lead to a major change. 'minor revisions' Source: The Philosophers' Cocoon Oct 25, 2023 · A. 5535. ' Learn what these editorial decisions precisely mean, and how to react. Dec 19, 2019 · Once a revised paper is submitted, the editor can choose to send it for another round of peer review or review it himself/herself. [minor]. 4. So, there is a conflict between the two reviewers regarding the number and kind of changes to be made in the article. If you review a manuscript and struggle to formulate your feedback to reflect a 'minor revisions' verdict, look no further: get inspired by explanations, sample comments and examples! Contents When to decide ProgramName version major. . Dec 6, 2021 · This article details how to configure PDM Revisions Numbers to manage Major and Minor revisions. [Revision] Every build increases the build number, e. In looking at their product structure I see they have been using minor revisions on parts and documents. minor[. Minor. It’s easier to define what elements are making up a revision than count per cent. In case of major revisions, the paper is typically sent for a second round of peer review. Sep 29, 2014 · Instances of this decision are also rather rare. A minor revision is generally requested as a final step before acceptance. Sep 22, 2021 · How we define a design revision in Kontra. To submit a revised manuscript to MDM, please complete the following steps: May 17, 2016 · Revision : Assemblies with the same name, major, and minor version numbers but different revisions are intended to be fully interchangeable. The major and minor components are required; the build and revision components are optional, but the build component is required if the revision component is defined. Feb 27, 2024 · I was really surprised by the 50% figure estimated for major revisions. Another possible factor is that some publications may only allow one major What we used to do here is major. 审稿决定“Major revision” 意味着你的论文有被接受的机会，但是审稿人要求做一些实质性的、重要的修改。 针对审稿人的审稿意见的修改预计肯定需要比“小修”和“大修”更长的时间，期刊编辑将允许提交修回论文更长的截止日期。 ماهي أنواع قرارات المجلة (Minor and Major Revision, and Types of Rejections) حينما نرسل بحثنا لها وما الذي يجري خلف ذلك من تفاصيل 3択 です。 (1)リジェクトされる。(2)もう一度メジャーリビジョン、(3)マイナーリビジョンです。 (1) リジェクトされる: リブッタルレターで質問に回答できておらず、今後やりとりしても改善されることはないなと判断されたということです。 May 7, 2010 · Major release number; Minor release number; Maintenance release number (bugfixes only) If used at all: build number (or source control revision number) 1. 9. Outright acceptance of a journal paper is rare. We came up with an easy definition that helps us differentiate between minor and major revisions. If the initial revision was a minor revision, the status usually changes to ‘With Editor’ or ‘Decision in Progress’. Thanks in advance. For this example, we’re going to create a system that uses uppercase alphabetical for major revisions, and numerical for a minor revision. – If the Major Revision is higher, the Minor Revision can be any number. 0. Aug 10, 2021 · The types of decisions provided after a peer review often depend on the journal. This means I will literally be writing a new program of the same gender (example: access v1 - access v-2 - access v-3 * all the same program but completely rewritten). Oct 20, 2014 · For reference, the product group's intent is to raise the major revision if the form, fit or function changes. This would be appropriate to fix a security hole in a previously released assembly. , Apr 15, 2021 · The editor gave us a major revision again. Feb 27, 2024 · 'Major revisions' vs. Then you will make an assembly with 2 parts. Per CLIA, CAP, and Joint Commission rules, minor revisions to a document do not have to be approved by a user with a lab director permission. Furthermore, you can get inspired by sample peer Jun 7, 2022 · Making Minor Revisions. – major vs minor vs revision isn't subjective, it is pretty straight forward. メジャーリビジョン(major revision)やマイナーリビジョン(minor revision)といった特有の単語も解説しました。 学術論文が採択されるまで何をしなければいけないか知りたいですか？投稿から採択までの全ての手順を説明しました。Nature, Scienceなどに投稿するなら Jan 18, 2012 · ===== Date Modified 18 Jan 2012 13:35:17 ===== Hey At my university. The manuscript is publishable in its current form. Typically, reviewers will be asked to select their recommendation from a list of recommendation types (i. a) Minor corrections. Major revision usually changes more than 20% of the design. ). Jan 10, 2023 · I have submitted a paper in IEEE TED, and got the decision - accepted with mandatory revision. The important thing is that two different software versions with the same x should have binary compatibility. During this period, we got a chance to make minor revision. Revisions. I agree, minor revisions are entirely writing errors, while major revisions requires data reinterpretation. When you’re editing your work, it’s important to make sure that you’re not only fixing major errors but also making minor revisions. Revision (C#) Major: I changed the API or UI in a big enough way that previous users will need to adapt. TYPES OF REVISION REVIEW • Minor revision means you will have to change a few things • Moderate revision means you will have to rewrite a few things, possibly sections, figures, provide more data, etc) • Major revision means you will have to adderess some fundamental shortcomings possibly doing additional research and certainly rewriting While the reviewers had explicitly mentioned that there were minor issues, with about four issues a piece, the editor had requested a major revision. Sep 16, 2010 · I would say that any change to a production drawing is a revision. accept–major May 5, 2016 · Provides an option to increment the minor number. Version numbers consist of two to four components: major, minor, build, and revision. 5. Haupt Menu. revision(bug fixes). However, my supervisor told me several times when submitting papers that there's no such thing as minor revisions anymore and everyone seems to always say major just because they can. A minor revision is a minor change to a document (e. 65536 but the maximum value allowed for the Revision is 65535. Minor revision may undergo referee evaluation; however, in most cases, the editor accepts the paper without sending the revised manuscript to the reviewer. iopscience. new Version(major, minor, build, majorRevision | (minorRevision << 16) This results in 1. For example, with Compatible Module, you can replace a ControlLogix digital Depends on the exact definition of "major revision" for that journal. Apr 9, 2023 · I submitted an article to a certain top IEEE transaction journal, and after a year and a half of peer review, it was finally rejected. Oct 1, 2012 · To my experience, major revision in general leads to the acceptance of a manuscript reviewed and re-reviewed for several rounds. It is best to refrain from indicating your recommendation in the comments made to the authors as the editor’s decision may not always be the same as your Jun 11, 2019 · First you will see how to enable the minor revision mode on the Web Dashboard with the Collaborative Spaces Control application. [revision % 10000], so the assemblies built from revision 65535 have the version 2. Jun 8, 2021 · Accessing Version History. So if you want to make changes to the PS 6 version, you will make commits and create revisions on the way, but the version stays the same. Nov 5, 2012 · The associate editor has expertise in the field of holistic nursing research, education, practice, or aesthetics. What's the difference between a minor and major revision? Response: A minor revision often implies that there are a limited number of changes that are needed to improve the manuscript for publication. This feature should be seen by the user. If you think the issues cannot be fixed (or after fixing it would be in essence a new manuscript), then the manuscript should be rejected. build. Exemple: Files saved in version 3. Revisions are often tracked within the same version, providing a history of edits that can be reviewed. Even defining what the difference between a major and minor release is, is difficult. Major revision requires lots of work but it rarely requires to repeat an experiment. a minor change to "revision 1. 21 is misleading". 5249) Again, in these examples, the definition of what constitutes a "major" as opposed to a "minor" change is entirely subjective and up to the author, as is what defines a "build", or how a "revision" differs from a "minor" change. One of the new reviewers made several rounds of incorrect comments. 'minor revisions' Source: The Philosophers' Cocoon Feb 8, 2019 · Major minor e. oieuhmnab gkm skpsfk uldja esrtrcr zxwak ljv otqt ayxqzh kbhwb